By Barry Rubin
I'll bet your mother said to you at least once: "If all your friends jumped off a cliff would you do it also?"
Secretary of State Hillary Clinton's statement on Libya reminded me of that kind of admonition:
"I would point out that Europe led the way in our response on Libya, and they were fully supported by the Arab League. So with respect to Libya, the United States is very willing to be part of this coalition, and we have contributed a great deal. But it was concern from Arab leaders and European leaders at the United Nations that really moved us forward with respect to Libya."
This is a very unusual U.S. government. It is eager to show that it isn't a leader. The underlying belief is that America must prove it isn't a bully so that the rest of the world will love it. What's important, however, is that in international affairs the strong are criticized but also get respect.
There is a strain in American political culture, from the founders, of not wanting to be too pushy in international affairs. At times in history this could shade off into isolationism, though that's pretty unlikely in today's world. Before the United States entered World War One, there was a slogan explaining that policy: Too proud to fight.
What the assassination of Usama bin Ladin proved is that America can get things done when it wants to do so. And also that it can act alone when necessary. It is less proof of President Barack Obama's brilliance and courage than it is of America's ability.
The question that must be foremost is whether a given action is in U.S. interests NOT whether it polishes the U.S. image. A willingness to be unpopular at times is a necessity for any country that wants to survive and prosper.
Just because the Arab League says it's ok is not a sufficient criterion for U.S. foreign policy to do something.
To be fair, I understand that this isn't precisely what Clinton is saying. I'm sure she would add that the intervention in Libya is in U.S. interests. But I still don't think that's true.
Moreover, this argument about what everyone else does becomes the rationale for not doing more about Iran or Syria. And one fears it will shape mistakes yet to come.
Barry Rubin is director of the Global Research in International Affairs (GLORIA) Center and editor of the Middle East Review of International Affairs (MERIA) Journal. His latest books are The Israel-Arab Reader (seventh edition), The Long War for Freedom: The Arab Struggle for Democracy in the Middle East (Wiley), and The Truth About Syria (Palgrave-Macmillan). The website of the GLORIA Center is at http://www.gloria-center.org and of his blog, Rubin Reports, http://www.rubinreports.blogspot.com.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Blog Archive
-
▼
2011
(1971)
-
▼
May
(370)
- Moshe Dayan's Progressive Hubris Made Jerusalem an...
- Interview With Ben Shapiro On His New Book Primeti...
- HE'S ALWAYS CLASSY: RAPPER "CLASSIFIED" CALLS ABOU...
- HE'S ALWAYS CLASSY: RAPPER "CLASSIFIED" CALLS ABOU...
- Homeless - Homeless Alcoholics Need A Wet House
- Major Oil Find in Texas, 3,000 Wells in 12 Months ...
- 5/31/2011 Playboy Tuesday Trivia Time!!!
- 5/31/2011 Playboy Tuesday Trivia Time!!!
- Egypt: Where Moderates and Judges Endorse Terrorism
- Consumer Confidence, Manufacturing And Housing- Mo...
- PBS Website Hackers LulzSec Praise Zennie62, Media...
- Subway Fights, NYC Naked Man Rants - How To Avoid...
- When Palestinian President Abbas Said NO To A Sett...
- Michael Jordan Biography
- Newsbusted: Did Obama Send Mitt Romney a Dead Fish?
- Why I haven't Covered Weinergate
- 5/31/2011 Playboy's 'Sole Mates'
- 5/31/2011 Playboy's 'Sole Mates'
- YouTube's Statement On Harrassment And Cyberbullying
- On Memorial Day, Remembering My Fathers
- This Weekend
- Barack Obama's "Muslim Problem"
- Extended Trailer For NBC's New TV Series: The Play...
- Extended Trailer For NBC's New TV Series: The Play...
- New Bavaria Beer Commercial Starring Hugh Hefner, ...
- New Bavaria Beer Commercial Starring Hugh Hefner, ...
- In One Sentence Here is What Obama Doesn't Unders...
- PBS, Sony, Fox Websites Hacked By LulzSec's Lulz B...
- Abraham Lincoln Biography
- Marilyn Monroe Biography
- Jennifer Lopez Biography
- Beliebers are not impressed with Selena Gomez.
- Jessica Alba and Cash Warren are expecting a girl!
- John Travolta remembers Jeff 'Kenickie' Conaway.
- Nick Lachey and Vanessa Minnillo celebrate their u...
- Tony Romo and Candice Crawford tie the knot.
- Golden State Warriors To Get Bigger Under Jerry West?
- The Key to Obama’s Foreign Policy: The World Turne...
- On Memorial Day Remember Those Who Kept us Free
- 99ers, HR 589 & the Unemployment Wars: U-Cubed Pic...
- Video Teaser: Coming Soon To Playboy's Cyber Club:...
- Video Teaser: Coming Soon To Playboy's Cyber Club:...
- Pre-Order: 'Sweet Karma' Starring Playboy Playmate...
- Pre-Order: 'Sweet Karma' Starring Playboy Playmate...
- Heather Rae Young's Arctic Adventure
- Heather Rae Young's Arctic Adventure
- Kim Kardashian got engaged
- YouTube, Stop Use Of The N-Word - An Update
- Leonardo da Vinci Biography
- Martin Luther Biography
- New 99er "Ex-Lax Attack" Campaign announced on Job...
- And The New Leader of the Free World Is...Saudi Ar...
- Cat mom hugs baby kitten
- Oakland Budget Talk At Kwik Way Burger Joint Grand...
- Jeff Conaway, Star Of 'Grease' And 'Taxi,' Dies At 60
- YouTube Stop The N-Word; Glee PSA Compares It To "...
- YouTube, Stop Use Of The N-Word - A Follow-Up
- New Poll: Almost Two-Thirds of Voters Want a Balan...
- YouTube, Stop Use Of The N-Word, For Brand's Sake
- Patients Satisfaction Surveys: Valid Test, Or Make...
- Lady Gaga Biography
- Nicki Minaj Biography
- Breaking Newsbusted News: Solution Found For Debt ...
- Arab World: Onward to Revolutionary Violence ? Or ...
- Playboy's 2011 Playmate Of The Year Claire Sinclai...
- Playboy's 2011 Playmate Of The Year Claire Sinclai...
- Kim Kardashian and Kris Humphries could make 5 mil...
- Bryce Dallas Howard expecting second child.
- The NY Times Lied About Israeli Reaction to Netan...
- Stupid CNN Tricks: Randy Kaye On Ed Schultz 'There...
- Sen Rand Paul Patriot Act Amendment Killed
- Tosh.0: "Stuff You Never Want to Hear Girls Say." ...
- Tosh.0: "Stuff You Never Want to Hear Girls Say." ...
- Top Black Democrat Declares Opposition to Obama Ba...
- Thirty Years Ago Menachem Begin Ordered The IAF To...
- Carla Bruni shows baby bump in maternity wear.
- Ryan Reynolds opens up about divorce.
- Vertex Incivek Patient Steve Goodwin On The FDA Ap...
- Elvis Presley Biography
- Beyonce Biography
- Kim Kardashian and Kris Humphries are sure about e...
- Kris Humphries asked future parents-in-law for Kim...
- Everything you want to know about Kim Kardashian's...
- Why There's No Peace, Who's Responsible, and What ...
- Tom Jones On American Idol, Mick Jagger On Grammys...
- Rob Woodall, Georgia GOP Congressman Health Care H...
- Cowardly President Obama Refuses To Address The Ke...
- Oakland Mayor Jean Quan In Las Vegas For ICSC, Why...
- Americans Say "Take This Electric Car And Shove It!"
- Obama Forgets History And Thus Makes Future Histor...
- Did Christopher Meloni Tip Law & Order: SVU Depart...
- WARNING: The Double Dip Recession Has Started
- Selena Gomez Biography
- Mother Teresa Biography
- Kim Kardashian and Kris Humphries are engaged!
- Walt Disney Biography
- Playboy Playmate Xtra Week 4 - Shera Bechard
- Playboy Playmate Xtra Week 4 - Shera Bechard
- Why The Issue of Land, Landed President Obama In ...
- Milli Vanilli film to be filmed this year. For rea...
-
▼
May
(370)
0 comments:
Post a Comment